Drug-Testing for Welfare Benefits April 13, Many states have implemented or discussed plans that require their welfare recipients to pass a drug test in order to be eligible for benefits. These policies have their proponents and opponents, and in this article Wonk Tank examines the arguments. Background Discussions of drug-testing welfare recipients began in earnest following the Federal Welfare Reform Act. Many states have considered or enacted legislation around this issue.
Fincher grew up in rural Tennessee, in a generational farm family. The Fincher family has found great assistance from the federal government to help his family in their farming endeavors.
Representative Stephen Fincher R-Tennessee introduced the Welfare Integrity Act of last week, which would require random drug testing for illegal substances for welfare applicants and recipients.
Fincher stated, "currently the federal government enables drug abusers a safety-net by allowing them to participate in the TANF program," Fincher said in a statement highlighted by the Huffington Post.
The common response from those who support this effort is, "Why should my hard earned tax dollars be used to pay for someone to use drugs". This is the driving sentiment behind what we are seeing throughout the country, a mass movement among Republicans at the state and federal level to implement welfare drug testing programs.
The efforts are earmarked more toward a misperception about those living in poverty rather than actual facts.
If they were about facts, then the prevailing feeling should apply to all "welfare "programs, including the programs that have aided Rep. Fincher and his family. Representative Fincher is my age 39 but as I grew up in the inner city, Mr.
According to several news sources, Fincher Farms, a family business run by Rep. Fincher grows cotton, corn, soybeans, and wheat on more than 2, acres in western Tennessee. Department of Agriculture data. Ok, so he received government assistance as a farmer, which is different than someone who lives in an urban area receiving government assistance.
He is probably not using it for drugs because he lives in a farming community and drug use is usually reserved to urban centers. That would also be a wrong assumption as those living in rural communities are more likely to be involved in drug abuse than those who live in urban communities.
According to a report by Karen Van Gundy out of the University of New Hampshire, entitled Substance Abuse in Rural and Small Town America, those in rural areas are more likely to use drugs than those living in urban communities.
Gundy states, "rural and urban places today have similar rates of substance use and abuse, and, for abuse of some substances, rural Americans are at an even higher risk than their urban counterparts.
Fincher should grab a pee cup now. Unfortunately this argument is not about the smart drug testing policy, it is more about demonizing and targeting the poor. As we saw in the results from Florida's drug testing policy, it yielded no significant results outlining drug use among welfare recipients.
Entitled the Demonstration Project by the State of Florida, Governor Rick Scott looked at the usage of substance abuse by welfare recipients in the state.
Over an eighteen-month period, the researchers on the Demonstration Project used a written test to screen over 8, TANF applicants for reasonable cause to believe they were substance abusers. Of those screened, applicants were identified as potential substance abusers and required to undergo urinalysis.
The researchers noted that this rate of drug use was lower than had been reported in other national studies of welfare recipients.
Ten years earlier, Florida conducted the same tests to the same results. According to PolitiFact, in the Florida Legislature "approved a drug-testing pilot project for people receiving temporary cash assistance.
But the results were underwhelming.
Of the 8, applicants screened for drugs, only 3. Having both grown up in poverty, engaged in the work of helping those living in poverty and now teaching social policy at the university level, I know that many actions related to the poor are often driven by misinformation.
What is different about the approaches of Gov. Fincher is that it is not misinformation that guides them because the data is in front of them.
What guides these approaches is a mistrust of those living in poverty and then devising terrible policy strategies to further marginalize and demonize the poor.
As a Mother Jones article by Claudia Jeffery stated in that "sincethe number of Americans living below the poverty line at any one time has steadily risen.
Fincher will have their hands full in finding ways to alienate this growing segment of American society. Do you have information you want to share with HuffPost?should people on disability or welfare be drug tested Abstract A drug test is an examination of biological material to distinguish the nearness medicates and decide earlier medication utilize.
Oct 17, · Out of 38, welfare applicants, 48 people got positive drug tests in Missouri. Utah blew $64, to catch 29 people who did llegal drugs. Arizona found 3, and Mississippi just 2. Persuasive essay about drug testing Drug Testing Welfare Recipients - Duration: by.
Drug Testing In Schools: Debate Paper - With A Free Essay Review - Free Essay Reviews. Stop biting on your nails and trying to come up with topics for persuasive essay.
There’s a great. Welfare And Drug Testing Term paper While the free essays can give you inspiration for writing, they cannot be used 'as is' because they will not meet your assignment's requirements.
If you are in a time crunch, then you need a custom written term paper on your subject (welfare and drug testing). Welfare Recipients Should Be Drug Tested Before Receiving Their Cash Benefits Over , residents of Minnesota are receiving welfare and other cash benefits.
(Serres 1) Welfare recipients in the United States should be required to pass a random drug test to qualify for welfare and other. Drug testing for cash welfare, meanwhile, has been in place since Clinton’s welfare reform. According to the AP, at least 15 states have passed laws that allow them to drug test recipients of Temporary Assistance for Needy Families, also known as TANF.